Citizens' Center for Nuclear Non-ProliferationRussian Nuclear Non-Proliferation Site
Main   Russian
Exclusive | Archive | Publications | About us | Links | Forum | Guestbook

By Max Fisher,
The Interpreter & The New York Times,
15 March 2017

Europe Is Facing 4 Existential Tests. Can It Hold Together?

The risk of European disintegration looks significantly more real this week. Multiple crises, each a symptom and cause of the continent`s deepest problems, are converging simultaneously.

Britain took a step toward leaving the European Union, and Scotland toward independence. The far right is expected to do well in Dutch elections. And a growing feud between the governments of Turkey and the Netherlands reveals both the difficulties of keeping Europe together and the forces that could pull it apart.

Alone, these are not enough to break apart Europe, which has endured worse. But they represent larger forces that, given enough such crises, could do just that. This week`s events, then, pose something of a test of whether Europe can overcome or at least manage its problems - or whether those problems are enough to unravel the post-World War II order.

Here is an overview of those crises and why they matter.

Far Right Likely to Gain in Dutch Election

The Netherlands will hold a national election on Wednesday in which the far-right Party for Freedom is expected to do well. It currently holds 15 of 150 seats in Parliament. Polls suggest that it will gain five to 15 additional seats, making it the country`s largest or second-largest party.

The party is led by Geert Wilders, a populist firebrand who is known for extreme anti-Islam positions.

It appears highly unlikely that Mr. Wilders or his party will end up leading the Netherlands. He would need 76 seats to form a governing majority, and the country`s multiparty system means that mainstream parties can easily form a coalition without him.

Still, the election is a test case for whether Europe, which will also see major elections in France and Germany this year, can manage its rising populist movements.

Far-right parties, even if they cannot secure enough seats to govern, can exert pressure. Mainstream parties could feel compelled to co-opt populist positions, much as Britain`s Conservative Party adopted leaving the European Union, or Brexit. And keeping the far right out of power risks exacerbating populist backlashes, as voters increasingly believe that establishment parties are conspiring to undermine popular will.

In this way, the real test is not Election Day, but how the mainstream handles the next few years with a smaller majority and an emboldened far right. In Germany and France as well, the far right is currently polled to win a larger slice of votes but not enough to take power.

The takeaway: The far right probably will not take power, but there will be more pressure to pursue populist policies, such as targeting migrants or weakening European integration, that would undermine Europe`s postwar order.

Turkey and Europe at Odds

A growing dispute between Turkey and European governments poses its own high-stakes test.

Turkish officials are touring Europe to hold rallies encouraging the Turkish diaspora to vote in support of a referendum next month that would give the country a new constitution that would greatly expand the powers of President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who has invested significant political capital in the measure.

But Germany and the Netherlands have blocked the rallies. The Netherlands prevented Turkey`s foreign minister from landing in the country and deported the Turkish family minister, in both cases to prevent them from attending pro-referendum rallies.

Mr. Erdogan responded by accusing both countries of Nazism.

The feud serves the political interests of both Turkish and Dutch leaders. For Mr. Erdogan, it allows him to make a show of standing up to Europe, rallying nationalists at home. Polls have shown a tight vote for the referendum, so he needs every vote.

Mark Rutte, the Dutch prime minister, also stands to gain votes among those skeptical of Mr. Erdogan. But so does Mr. Rutte`s primary challenger, Mr. Wilders, who has seized the crisis to portray the country`s Turkish minority as alien and hostile.

Because governments on both sides are driven largely by domestic electoral politics, they may decide, after their respective votes, that it is in their interest to smooth things over.

Or they may not. The Dutch government is likely to emerge under pressure from a larger far right. And Mr. Erdogan, if his referendum passes and he consolidates power away from democratic institutions, may still feel insecure. Both could respond by indulging more such disputes. With each round, they could whip up more public outrage against the other, making it harder for either to back down.

The episode, then, is less a danger in itself than a test of whether Europe and Turkey can still get along.

That is a question of values as Europe swings toward populism and Turkey toward authoritarianism. But it is also a practical matter: Europe needs Turkey to stem the arrival of refugees, which it has been doing under a year-old deal.

Mr. Erdogan, if pushed, could cancel the deal and allow or send millions into Europe. A rapid influx could deeply destabilize European politics and fuel the far right at a delicate moment.

The takeaway: Turkey and Europe both have interests in getting along, but political pressures could eventually build to the point of forcing a breakup that hurts everyone.

Article 50 Brings Brexit Closer

The British Parliament approved legislation that would permit Prime Minister Theresa May to formally invoke Article 50 of a European Union treaty, which dictates how a member state leaves the union.

This legislation is mostly procedural. The debate has largely focused on how to carry out Britain`s exit from the European Union - what role Parliament has in negotiations, for instance, and whether European Union citizens should retain certain rights - rather than over whether the exit will occur. British leaders are still set on leaving.

The larger significance is that it brings Ms. May a step closer to triggering Article 50, which she had pledged to do by the end of this month and which would officially begin the process of leaving the European Union.

Once Article 50 is invoked, Britain will be effectively locked in to leaving the European Union. It will have two years to negotiate the terms of exiting, over things like trade agreements and migration rules.

If there is no agreement within that time - which seems possible given how much there is to hammer out - then the country will be ejected with no agreement. No one knows for sure what that would mean. Britain is desperate for this to go smoothly, but the European Union has every incentive to make this process painful so as to deter other European states from following.

The takeaway: Brexit is looking increasingly certain, which will heavily damage both the British economy and European unity.

Scotland and Northern Ireland in Doubt

Nicola Sturgeon, the first minister of Scotland, has called for a new independence referendum, which would make Scotland an independent country with the aim of remaining within the European Union. The vote would be held by spring 2019, so almost certainly while Britain is still negotiating Brexit.

Ms. Sturgeon`s statement is not binding, and there are many steps to go. She cannot hold a referendum without permission from the British government, and it is unclear whether she will get it.

Scottish voters defeated a 2014 referendum 55 percent to 45 percent. But Brexit could tilt the politics. Most Scots voted to stay in the European Union, and Brexit feels, to many, like proof that Scottish and English voters do not share a common vision for the country and that the more populous English will continue to impose their conservative politics on Scotland.

Economic conditions, though, are less favorable to independence. An independent Scotland would rely heavily on exports of oil, the price of which has plummeted since 2014.

Less noticed has been the recent election in Northern Ireland, which handed major gains to Sinn Fein, a nationalist party that has called for Northern Ireland to leave Britain and reunite with Ireland.

Brexit has brought tremendous uncertainty to the Northern Ireland peace agreements, which rely on relaxed Irish border rules that may no longer be possible after Brexit. Sinn Fein still lacks a majority, but its gains indicate Northern Irish skepticism about following Britain out of the European Union.

The takeaway: The United Kingdom could break apart, though it is too early to say whether it will.

Your opinion (comments to the article)?

Your name:

Your comments:

Please enter the code exactly as shown in image format.


  • Russia Just Fired a Hypersonic Missile from a MiG-31 Fighter. Should America be Worried?. By Dave Majumdar, The National Interest, 14 March 2018

  • Trump Denies Russian Guilt in Murder. Tillerson Admits It, Is Fired. Hmm.. By Jonathan Chait, New York Magazine, 14 March 2018

  • Chairman of nuclear weapons oversight agency steps down amid internal turmoil. By Patrick Malone, Center for Public Integrity, USA Today, 9 February 2018

  • Generals Want Money for Yesterday`s Cold War. The top U.K. general knows the real battlefield is virtual. So why does he still demand more money for conventional weapons?. By Leonid Bershidsky, Bloomberg, 24 January 2018

  • Can the U.S. and Russia work together? A new poll suggests some shared foreign policy goals. By Adam Taylor, The Washington Post, 20 January 2018

  • How U.S. Intelligence Agencies Underestimated North Korea. By David E. Sanger, William J. Broad, The New York Times, 9 January 2018

  • These Are the Top 10 Risks to the World in 2018. The risk of a "geopolitical depression" forms the backdrop for the top 10 risks of 2018, according to the Eurasia Group. By Ian Bremmer, Time, 5 January 2018
  • Advertising
    Exclusive | Archive | Publications | About us | Links | Forum | Guestbook
    Home   Up   Back

    General Post Office, P.B. 25211, Krasnoyarsk, 600000. Russia.
    © 2000. Design: